TERRY GROSS, HOST:
That is FRESH AIR. I am Terry Gross. One of many frontiers of drugs entails manipulating the naturally occurring electrical fields in our our bodies. Every of the 40 trillion cells in your physique is like its personal little battery with its personal little voltage, writes my visitor, Sally Adee. Her new e-book, “We Are Electrical,” is about how medical and tech researchers are experimenting with attainable methods to control the physique’s electrical fields to deal with or remedy ailments and situations, together with melancholy, wounds, damaged bones, most cancers and paralysis. Most likely the best-known already current instance of electrical medication is the pacemaker to maintain the center beating at an acceptable tempo. Tiny, remote-controlled mind implants are getting used to deal with the signs of Parkinson’s illness. Electrical medication can take the type of implants, wearable units, shocks or electrical medicine. The important thing to the way forward for electrical medication is mapping the physique’s electrical alerts in order that we all know what to repair when one thing goes improper.
Sally Adee is a science and tech author and the previous options editor on the New Scientist. Sally Adee, welcome to FRESH AIR. That is actually fascinating stuff. I realized a lot about my physique. So let’s begin with one thing private. You participated in a navy experiment. You tried it out. And the aim was to see whether or not sending {an electrical} present by a selected a part of the mind would enhance alertness and focus. So mainly, you got what seems like a online game the place you needed to, like, , shoot the enemy ‘trigger it is a navy coaching train. So the aim was to see, , earlier than and after – earlier than {the electrical} present how you probably did and in case your accuracy as a marksman, as a shooter was improved after this electrical present to sharpen your focus. So simply describe the sport slightly bit.
SALLY ADEE: Certain. So that is known as DARWARS Ambush. And I assume it was a coaching simulation to be able to be taught, , marksmanship. They mainly mentioned that slightly tiny bit {of electrical} present utilized to electrodes on both aspect of your head – what it could do was lower the time it could take to get from novice to skilled by one thing like an element of two. And so I actually needed to grasp the way it labored, however I could not discuss to anyone who had undertaken these experiments. And so after a number of cajoling, they let me fly over there to California on this kind of grey workplace park inside which one room had been kind of kitted out with sandbags and, like, a close-range fight rifle, which was solely firing CO2 rounds, however it was hooked into this simulation, which was, , like, a first-person shooter, like, mainly designed to show you accuracy in goal taking pictures.
And so I began out – I used to be horrible, however that they had me do all of those drills, and it was so discouraging. And I simply stored considering, I simply need this to be over. And the entire time that they have me doing these drills, I’m related to the gadget, which has a battery at the back of my bra mainly, in order that I can not see whether or not the gadget is on or not. And I’ve received the 2 electrodes, presumably lively, presumably not. So I am in there for, I feel, what appears like hours. You recognize, it is this, like, online game form of factor the place persons are coming at you, and also you’re supposed to guard the bottom. And I simply preserve getting blown up and blown up and blown up, and I simply can not get higher at this. And I used to be simply beginning to panic slightly bit. I’ve received a number of, like, kind of indignant self-recrimination, and I am like, that is all a rip-off. And I simply – I’ve received simply, like, a number of wasps in my head at this level.
After which he comes again in, and he fiddles with the gadget. After which the subsequent spherical was a totally completely different expertise. It appears like all of the wasps have been herded out of the room. And unexpectedly this simulation or no matter that had been so difficult and overwhelming out of the blue was extremely simple. Like, I might simply very simply inform who’s the primary, , kind of attacker that I want to select off and who’s the subsequent one. And it was simply so easy unexpectedly. And the tech is available in, and she or he’s like, all proper, , you are carried out. And I assumed, nicely, , lastly, I am getting the hold of this. Can I simply, like, go – and I used to be like, did I get all of them? And he or she mentioned, yeah. And I used to be like, nicely, the place’s the remainder? And he or she mentioned, no, it is over. And what had been 20 minutes felt like three minutes to me. And it was, like, a very profound expertise that, , stayed with me till immediately.
GROSS: Wait, the expertise stayed with you or the change in how your thoughts works modified – stayed with you?
ADEE: Just a little little bit of column A, slightly little bit of column B, as a result of the expertise, like, the reminiscence of it, was profound ‘trigger it wasn’t simply that have. Like, then for the remainder of the day, the whole lot simply received slightly simpler. Like, once I was driving again in LA site visitors, mainly – Southern California site visitors – I am often fairly a nervous, white-knuckling form of a driver, and that was fairly uncomplicated as nicely. I simply form of received on with it with out all of the self-recrimination and all of the kind of ritualistic self-abuse that usually accompanies all – it is just like the elevator music in my mind, and it was carried out. After which, , for the subsequent three days, it was kind of, like, a delicate downslope from that. You recognize, I simply kind of reintegrated into my life. Nevertheless it stayed with me until immediately as a result of out of the blue it had supplied me a brand new manner of taking a look at my brainscape as a result of I assumed, nicely, hold on. Like, I did not know that there are such a lot of wasps in my mind. After which, yeah, simply to this present day I feel that basically modified issues for me.
GROSS: So is the navy truly utilizing these units now for coaching individuals?
ADEE: Have you learnt what? I do not know, to be sincere. I do not know – I am undecided that they’d as a result of as I discovered afterwards, the article that I wrote about this was extra about electrical methods of inducing the circulate state, which is that this – , that is in all probability in all places now. Stream is that this state that you just get into, this excellent state of mastery over, , no matter it’s that you just’re doing, whether or not it is, , writing or carpentry or sharpshooting, individuals began saying, like, nicely, truly tDCS – transcranial direct present stimulation, which was the gadget that I might been sporting – tDCS cannot presumably work. You recognize, there was an enormous meta evaluation out of Australia a few years later, and the researchers had mentioned that we have, , checked out the entire various things that tDCS is meant to assist with – as a result of within the meantime that they had been researching it for, like, melancholy, nervousness, OCD, , focus, no matter – and so they mentioned once we common out all of the research, it does not do something.
GROSS: So the place can we stand now with it?
ADEE: And so I began to get actually nervous. So OK, while you return, the issue with a number of the research that had been carried out is that they have been nearly much like what I did, the place you have got a very low variety of people who find themselves having tDCS. Like, and that is actually necessary. That is an necessary step in science, is to have the research which can be carried out with a really small variety of individuals. However they cannot be the tip consequence, proper? That may’t be the factor that you just report, and also you say, like, tDCS cures melancholy. What they’ve discovered afterwards is that tDCS is tremendous onerous to get proper as a result of you must account for therefore many parameters. You need to account for issues like whether or not that particular person drank espresso that morning. You need to account for the cranium thickness. You need to account for the entire stuff.
And so the rationale I am telling you all it is because after this text got here out after which all of those different kind of tDCS does not work, sure, it does, , kind of back-and-forth sniping, I used to be like, what the hell occurred to me? I used to be like, did I fall for the placebo impact? Was I simply fully improper about all of this? After which individuals began speaking about, like, these, , 100-year-old electro quackery units. And I began taking a look at these, and I am like, oh, crap. Like, , they’ve had these things. They’d these things within the 1800s. There have been like electrical penis belts and, like – sorry, like, simply, – only a wild quantity of, like, electro quackery when electrical energy was first found.
So I used to be actually nervous that I had gotten it improper. And the factor that was wild is that then I began asking individuals, like, look, how is that this meant to work? And other people simply stored kind of repeating this kind of, nicely, nerves that fireplace collectively wire collectively. And I used to be like, however how does it work? And that is finally how I discovered about ion channels. After which I fell down, like, I do not know, like, a seven-year rabbit gap, and this e-book is the consequence.
GROSS: So I began off being, like, actually, actually enthusiastic about electrical medication, and now I am discouraged since you informed me that this perhaps does not work, that the research that you just have been inspecting wasn’t actually sufficiently big to offer a very correct appraisal of whether or not transcranial…
ADEE: Direct present stimulation.
GROSS: There you go – whether or not it actually works or not. So anyhow, there’s actually truly a number of encouraging issues occurring on this area.
ADEE: Yeah. No. I imply, that is precisely…
GROSS: So let’s elevate our spirits and get to a few of these. However let’s begin with slightly little bit of rationalization first. It is onerous for me to fathom that there is a lot electrical energy operating by my physique that it may be manipulated for medical causes. So that you say each one in all our 40 trillion cells is its personal little battery with its personal little voltage. What’s the operate of all this electrical energy? How does the mind use it to speak to the remainder of the physique? And what different features does the electrical energy serve?
ADEE: So the mind communicates with the remainder of the physique, and the remainder of the physique communicates with the mind through voltage spikes in neurons and muscle cells. So that you mainly – you have got that tiny voltage within the cell. It is a sign. In reality, , a number of neuroscientists seek advice from it because the neural code. Like – and so they assume, like, this, , kind of sample of spiking underpins issues like how reminiscences are fashioned and, , how sensations are transmitted. And there have been a number of actually fascinating implants which have proven which you can truly, for instance, , make an individual who maybe has no sensation of their hand, for instance – you may make them really feel sensation of their hand by touching the correct kind of assortment of neurons in that a part of the mind electrically by kind of stimulating them electrically. And that is – , that is kind of settled science. So mainly, that is the neural bioelectricity.
I imply, neuroscience is tremendous necessary. However in a manner, it is form of overshadowed the non-neural element of bioelectricity, which – there is a researcher at Tufts College known as Mike Levin, and he has appeared into a number of the bioelectricity of, like, improvement and regeneration and wound therapeutic. They usually assume that the nervous system is one layer of communication within the physique that is operating atop a a lot deeper, older layer of communication within the physique that can be bioelectric. And that is the stuff that is accountable for the way you develop your form within the womb, the way you heal, like, whether or not your cells will go rogue and develop into cancerous. I imply, it is like – it is wild how a lot stuff there – how a lot analysis there’s on these things.
GROSS: Effectively, I wish to discuss with you extra about how electrical energy is being utilized in medication. However first, we’ve to take a brief break. In the event you’re simply becoming a member of us, my visitor is science and tech author Sally Adee, writer of the brand new e-book “We Are Electrical.” We’ll be proper again. That is FRESH AIR.
(SOUNDBITE OF TODD SICKAFOOSE’S “TINY RESISTORS”)
GROSS: That is FRESH AIR. Let’s get again to my interview with science and tech author Sally Adee, writer of the brand new e-book “We Are Electrical,” a couple of new frontier in medication, treating ailments by manipulating our our bodies’ naturally occurring electrical alerts.
Let’s discuss slightly bit about most cancers as a result of I discovered this actually fascinating. A number of most cancers analysis is specializing in genetics. What are the genetic precursors and genetic adjustments in cancerous cells, and the way can we assault most cancers by understanding extra of the genetics? However there’s an alternate manner of taking a look at it, which is wanting on the electrical system within the physique. And also you say when wholesome cells flip cancerous, their electrical signaling adjustments radically. How does it change?
ADEE: Proper. So that is analysis that was carried out by Mustafa Djamgoz at Imperial Faculty within the – in London within the Nineteen Nineties. He discovered that while you have a look at most cancers cells below an oscilloscope, you’ll be able to see that they start to exhibit that spiking kind of voltage change sample that I used to be speaking about in neurons. They’re doing that regardless that they haven’t any enterprise doing it. And what he thinks is occurring is that these cells – there is a new ion channel that is been expressed, and it is inflicting them to start out spiking in a communication sort of manner. And he thinks that that’s a part of how they resolve whether or not to develop into invasive.
GROSS: So what’s an ion channel?
ADEE: An ion channel is a pore within the cell membrane that decides which ion will get to come back into the cell and which ion does not get to come back into the cell. So you have got completely different ion channels for various ions. So for instance, sodium, which is a charged molecule – if it tries to get into your neuron, the ion channel – the potassium channels are like, no, no thanks. You are going to keep on the market – nearly like slightly bouncer. They’re similar to, no. And what they do is that they’ll let the potassium ions in. And the entire cause that this issues is as a result of when you have got potassium contained in the cell in a unique focus than it’s outdoors the cell, your cell membrane acts, basically, like slightly battery. So your cell has a voltage. It has its personal voltage. And people voltages are completely different in numerous sorts of cell. Nerve cells are completely different voltages than pores and skin cells, bone cells, musculoskeletal tissue, liver cells.
GROSS: And that is the place most cancers is available in. The cost – the voltage or no matter of the most cancers cells are completely different…
ADEE: Yeah.
GROSS: …Than the – than…
ADEE: Yeah.
GROSS: …Wholesome cells.
ADEE: So as soon as a wholesome cell kind of abandons ship and decides that it may simply be, like, a ravenous, invasive most cancers cell, its voltage adjustments radically. And what you are able to do with an ion channel drug is change {the electrical} state of that cell by messing with the ion channels. And in tadpole experiments – and that is early days, however that is transferring actually quick. In tadpole experiments, they have been in a position to make use of ion channel medicine to maintain cells that had been genetically engineered to be tumors from altering their electrical voltage, proper? And with out doing any form of genetic mucking round, they stored these tumors from forming in tadpoles that had been genetically engineered to specific tumors.
And what’s extra thrilling is that what in addition they have been in a position to do is take cells that had already develop into cancerous, and simply by dialing their electrical energy – their electrical profile – again to wholesome electrical identification, they – it was like an undo swap. The most cancers cells turned wholesome once more. And so that is early days. I’ve to say this. This isn’t one thing that they’ve carried out in individuals. However the larger image that is painted by all of this disparate analysis is displaying us that electrical energy – bioelectricity can exert management over issues like genetics. So it is like a robust management swap.
GROSS: So inform us extra about how this interprets to treating most cancers. Would they be utilizing, like, channel blockers to dam sure, , like, calcium or sodium from getting into…
ADEE: Yeah.
GROSS: …The cells?
ADEE: Effectively, so ion channel blocking medicine, it seems to be prefer it is likely to be attainable to dam a sure explicit form of ion channel that varieties on cells as soon as they’ve develop into cancerous. So many scientists assume that for those who have been in a position to, for instance, preserve a tumor that you’ve from metastasizing, you can preserve most cancers as a continual illness and you can reside with it for, like, 10 or 20 years. And, , metastasis is what kills individuals in most cancers. So for those who had a tumor that basically needs to invade and eat and then you definitely kneecap it is ion channels which can be letting it truly categorical the habits that is going to let it invade and eat and unfold, then, yeah, that is a strategy to preserve most cancers continual. And I feel that is the very first thing that we will see. After which this early tadpole work of with the ability to change the cell voltage in order that the cells mainly backpedal from most cancers to well being, I feel that is down the highway slightly bit.
GROSS: That sounds very thrilling. So hopefully, scientists will work out a strategy to harness what you are speaking about and use it to deal with most cancers. So let’s transfer on to one thing that’s going to be one thing only a few individuals learn about, which is that there are experiments now about how electrical medication can be utilized to assist heal wounds.
ADEE: Sure.
GROSS: So what’s the precept behind that? Does wounded tissue emit a unique electrical sign than wholesome tissue?
ADEE: Sure. Sure, that is precisely proper. If you reduce your self, the – all of the ions within the pores and skin, they simply circulate out. It is like a brief circuit – , the whole lot – it is known as the wound present. And the wound present generates an electrical area. And the factor in regards to the electrical area is that it attracts these cells from across the physique, the macrophages, that are just like the little, , mop-up janitor guys. It attracts, like, the restore cells. And all of those cells which can be essential to restore a wound and scar it over, these issues, all of them present up proper useless middle in the midst of your wound. And this electrical area, while you first reduce your self, it is fairly large. It is like a loud sign. And because the wound heals over, this wound present will get much less and fewer pronounced till if you end up healed over, it is fully gone. There isn’t any detecting it.
GROSS: So what are the implications for electrical medication in treating wounds?
ADEE: Effectively, for those who might work out methods to amplify this wound present or manipulate it in a roundabout way, you can truly pace up wound therapeutic in all types of wounds as a result of all tissues have this, it is not simply pores and skin, , muscle and bone. In the event you might work out methods to pace it up. As – , some early analysis has discovered that it may very well be attainable with electrical stimulation to hurry up wound therapeutic.
GROSS: In the event you’re simply becoming a member of us, my visitor is science and tech author Sally Adee, writer of the brand new e-book, “We Are Electrical.” We’ll be again after a brief break. I am Terry Gross, and that is FRESH AIR.
(SOUNDBITE OF BRAD MEHLDAU AND MARK GUILIANA’S “LUXE”)
GROSS: That is FRESH AIR. I am Terry Gross. Let’s get again to my interview with science and tech author Sally Adee, writer of the brand new e-book “We Are Electrical.” It is a couple of new frontier in medication, treating ailments and situations with electrical energy. It is primarily based on understanding the physique’s pure electrical energy after which manipulating it. We all know that genetic irregularities could make us susceptible to cancers and different illness. Electrical medication relies on understanding what’s gone improper with the physique’s electrical system.
Scientists try to grasp programs, like mapping the genome so we perceive extra about genetics and methods to goal sure ailments once we’re treating them. After which there’s additionally the microbiome, which is knowing all of the completely different good and unhealthy organisms in our intestine and the way we are able to deal with digestive issues by understanding these organisms and making an attempt to keep up a wholesome steadiness of them as a substitute of an unhealthy system within the microbiome. Equally, scientists working with electrical medication try to grasp what’s being known as the electrome. What’s the electrome, and why does that maintain the important thing to electrical medication?
ADEE: So the electrome is a time period that is been steadily effervescent up in bioelectricity analysis over the previous, I feel, seven years or so. And the electrome refers to all {the electrical} dimensions and properties of our cells and tissues and, , entire organisms. And what they’re making an attempt to get at is, how do all of those electrical dimensions hyperlink up with one another, , just like the cells – how do they hyperlink up with, , {the electrical} properties of a whole tissue, like a whole organ, for instance? But additionally, how do they join with the opposite -omes (ph) that you just have been simply speaking about? You recognize, how does bioelectricity interface with genetics? How does it interface with the whole lot else?
And, , we have recognized, and it is develop into more and more clear over the previous 100 years that each one life is electrical. So the query is, like, why is it electrical? Like, what’s it doing? They usually’re making an attempt to check how electrical energy has energy over different points of biology. And I assume the very best place to start out kind of speaking about that’s the manner that bioelectric alerts might management, , how we’re formed within the womb.
GROSS: So once we discuss how, , infants are fashioned within the womb to seem like infants with, , eyes and nostril and all that, we often discuss stem cells, however it is a completely different manner of taking a look at it. That is about taking a look at it by {an electrical} perspective. So what is the distinction?
ADEE: So when a fertilized egg kind of, , differentiates into all of the cells that it may develop into, the massive query is, how does it know, , methods to type itself into, like, a regulation-issue human that we are able to all acknowledge – two arms and two legs and eyes on the entrance, no matter? The particulars, such as you mentioned, like the attention colour and the hair colour and all that stuff – that is decided by genetics. However what in regards to the basic form? How does it know that there is two eyes on the entrance and your ft face ahead and your butt is behind you? There’s nothing about that within the genome. Like, DNA does not have spatial data.
So there’s rising proof that there are bioelectric parameters that truly type a form of blueprint that tells the physique methods to take form. In order that they did this wonderful experiment. Dany Adams – she was engaged on Mike Levin’s lab at Tufts, and so they injected tadpoles, growing tadpoles, with one thing known as a voltage dye, which mainly takes voltage and simply converts it into one thing you’ll be able to see with the bare eye like a brightness. And so she’s watching these growing tadpoles. They do not have faces but. They’re simply blobs.
In some unspecified time in the future throughout improvement, unexpectedly there’s this, like, shimmer, this electrical shimmer, over the tadpole. And it is like a kind of ghostly pre-pattern of eyes and jaw and mouth. After which it goes away. And that is voltage, . That is voltage you are seeing. That is electrical.
After which a number of hours later, precisely the place that was, precisely the identical form of eyes and jaw and the whole lot else begins to type. And you’ll see that these electrical alerts – they have been like a blueprint that was instructing the physique the place to place the face and the way and what the form is. They usually assume that that is truly instrumental for a way all of our tissues type. You recognize, that is – I feel that is the half that is actually fascinating, that, , the genes get turned on after, however one way or the other there’s, like, one thing within the electrical alerts that’s instructing the physique methods to type itself.
GROSS: I do not know if that is a part of the identical experiment or not, however this fascinated me. There was an experiment during which, by some form of electrical stimulation or interference, a frog grew eyes in varied locations on the physique the place eyes…
ADEE: Sure.
GROSS: …Do not belong. Inform us about that.
ADEE: Yeah. So the subsequent factor they did after they noticed this ghostly pre-pattern, they have been like, nicely, , what occurs if we mess with simply the flexibility for this frog embryo to have the electrical sample, proper? In order that they used ion channel blockers to be sure that the frog embryo could not do these voltages. And after they did that, the frog embryos had horrible delivery defects as a result of these pre-patterns weren’t simply, like, , kind of random flashes. They have been causative.
And after that they have been like, nicely, wait a second, does that imply that we are able to truly exactly manipulate the physique sample? And that is the place these experiments began. They manipulated components of the tadpole to specific the identical sorts of voltages that might result in an eye fixed. They have been in a position to develop eyes on a frog’s intestine. There was one the place they grew an eye fixed on a frog’s butt, and it was gentle delicate.
So, I imply, , who is aware of? Like, sooner or later, , you in all probability don’t desire an eye fixed rising in your butt, however, like, what about – what if we develop eyes on the again of our head?
GROSS: Now, on a sensible degree, this is applicable to regeneration medication. What’s regeneration medication?
ADEE: Completely. Effectively, regenerative medication is kind of an umbrella time period that brings in, , stem cells, prosthetics and, , all this stuff which can be making an attempt to interchange what has been misplaced within the physique. If like, for instance, if, , you want a brand new liver otherwise you’ve, , misplaced an arm, , that is all a part of the identical concept. And this is without doubt one of the most promising, I feel, purposes of bioelectricity as a result of proper now there’s a number of work making an attempt to determine methods to get the physique to regrow you one thing as a substitute of going by all this hassle to attempt to create, , scaffolding of bone after which seed in stem cells and attempt to manipulate the genetics. Like, they assume that perhaps you’ll be able to simply kind of activate the bioelectric code of improvement that I used to be simply speaking about with the entire, , patterning your form factor. They assume that perhaps for those who might simply get the physique to show that again on once more later in life, it might simply develop you a brand new factor that you just want, like, and you may simply kind of not micromanage it, however let it do its personal factor, let it kick-start that course of by itself. Does that make sense?
GROSS: Effectively, it sounds outstanding.
ADEE: Yeah. Yeah, it does. It sounds science fiction, however, , Michael Levin at Tufts College – he likes to say, I feel that on the finish of the day, each drawback that we’ve, whether or not it is therapeutic wounds or most cancers or improvement, all of it comes all the way down to the identical primary query of how do you get a group of, like, 40 trillion brokers to do what you need them to do as a substitute of what they wish to do? That is what, I assume, unites this kind of bioelectricity analysis.
GROSS: Is there something that you just’re most enthusiastic about proper now, that you just assume has essentially the most promise, primarily based on what you have studied?
ADEE: So I feel it is not anybody explicit factor, though I’m enthusiastic about a number of stuff, particularly the stuff round wound therapeutic. However I feel it is extra of like a kind of generalized pleasure, proper? So within the nineteenth century round now, just like the 1820s or so, we had, like, two little instruments. We had, like, a – , the primary electrometer, after which we had, like, the kind of proto-battery. And we’re beginning to – and we have been beginning to, like, examine, nicely, what’s electrical energy actually? How does it work? And, , we’re excellent at – we have been simply initially of this query.
By the tip of the nineteenth century, there have been avenue lights lighting up London. We had the primary telegraph wire that was connecting continents. We had the primary energy line. Electrolysis had put, like, 50 new parts on the periodic desk. And now you kind of quick ahead, and we’re in 2023, and we have these, like, wonderful instruments.
We have, like, that voltage dye I used to be telling you about. We have ion channel medicine. We have, like, , optogenetics. We have now all of those instruments now, and so they’re advancing, . They preserve spawning larger insights, which then result in, like, higher instruments, which then spawn higher insights. And it is form of snowballing.
So I simply – like, I – , by the tip of this century, like, will we be calling, like, the twenty first century the bioelectric century? Like, I simply assume – I can not – , I wish to reside until the tip of the twenty first century so I might see this.
GROSS: Sally Adee, thanks a lot for speaking with us.
ADEE: Thanks a lot for having me.
GROSS: Sally Adee is the writer of the brand new e-book “We Are Electrical.” After we take a brief break, jazz critic Kevin Whitehead can have an appreciation of Wayne Shorter, who died March 2. And John Powers will inform us why he is excited in regards to the new movie “Return To Seoul.” That is FRESH AIR.
(SOUNDBITE OF CHARLIE HUNTER QUARTET’S “MIGHTY MIGHTY”)
Copyright © 2023 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional data.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This textual content will not be in its last type and could also be up to date or revised sooner or later. Accuracy and availability might range. The authoritative file of NPR’s programming is the audio file.
